对盟军环礁登岛战役的实验

黑豹G

实验场地：环礁岛屿萨塔瓦尔Satawal、9级城防、盟军从沃勒爱Wuleai出发。
9 g/ h( c# Y' }) \% u实验兵力：盟军18个师    陆战1、2、3、4师，第3、6、7、24、25、27、30、37、40、41、43步兵师，骑1师，
$ z. `0 O9 Q+ t+ h7 V                 亚美利加师，澳大利亚第6师。   第18、19、47战斗工兵团，11个坦克营，17个炮兵团，中太平洋司令部，( n* w; y8 [6 S
                 美第6集团军，美第3，9，10军。
1 F* x$ C; Q. J" v                 日军兵力 吴镇守府第1、2陆战队，第44、62、63、64海警队，日本陆军132基地部队，第33军司令部。
4 W$ i$ W0 G. A* h' f$ \: `$ s战斗过程：由盟军22艘CV轰炸3天，登陆当天16艘BB分两队进行炮击。. v0 q' E& x$ w" R  K; [
战斗评价：重锤砸鸡蛋，毫无悬念，3支部队直接被歼灭，战斗工兵将城防直接从9降到3。
8 `2 m  G; U# N( ^& b8 o) w$ j战斗报告：Ground combat at Satawal
: Y# e1 }2 Z+ f7 r% Z
4 H7 e' m- W& [3 g" c                  Allied Shock attack2 f. i1 a& C8 r# _. z' J/ ]
% n' s8 O# H# z
                  Attacking force 230295 troops, 2040 guns, 548 vehicles, Assault Value = 5624
9 i9 k: T, C: a$ `6 V
( T' o3 N/ E  }# l* f                  Defending force 23017 troops, 45 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 587
6 U* a( E8 G- [) T6 a: m+ M  }$ y, P& P& T
                  Allied engineers reduce fortifications to 31 s% z7 L5 e, Z( K, r# Y6 g9 r

9 L0 p! ~9 }" U1 t                  Allied max assault: 8784 - adjusted assault: 4806
& e0 A2 B0 Q5 B' n
- A8 l! `5 c. t                  Japanese max defense: 381 - adjusted defense: 95
  @7 R& A/ D# d! Y4 |8 z
6 L* [" H- W7 `% g$ z- j                  Allied assault odds: 50 to 1 (fort level 3) ' W4 b  x5 O8 V9 c! ~- i- l
' H9 T& V# P; H, i, m
                  Allied forces CAPTURE Satawal base !!!5 V' e# @! ~5 H" Y
6 L: Y$ O* N% m
) p9 N5 X9 ^2 U( k/ ^% ^! W
                  Japanese ground losses:& @- b: H8 \1 o7 O! r& r* q
                  5806 casualties reported# ^$ y4 F/ n( y" h
                  Guns lost 30& M" ^0 G6 F& }  E; H& ?" `, t

$ q( q$ p; R4 O( G; f0 x/ C8 W                  Allied ground losses:/ z9 ]6 p1 r' v5 H4 {& B+ ~
                  5263 casualties reported7 g! e7 X' p( c6 F/ o/ w) ?
                  Guns lost 128
- V/ o, }; b) M8 ?) ^7 r+ u: u                  Vehicles lost 86& X8 U: e9 N! ~

; g# [/ d+ D; e/ e4 Q[ 本帖最后由 黑豹G 于 2007-12-4 19:20 编辑 ]

黑豹G

盟军兵力减少，为陆战1、2、3、4师，澳大利亚第6师，全部的装甲和辅助部队，火力准备不变。4 f3 l, P* y* z
战斗结果：
1 A, `( B/ [! W# _% A3 PGround combat at Satawal/ ~* i# ~$ d( @8 q+ |2 c, m
$ Y/ L0 z! }8 s- c$ l, ~5 t) s
Allied Shock attack: E/ y8 S/ q% B" x% Z

2 i. W7 z4 z) g8 ~3 S# g+ Z8 h$ MAttacking force 77949 troops, 685 guns, 548 vehicles, Assault Value = 2044; ~$ u3 x- D# K5 G

: u, s. `  |/ H) f$ X2 P( n0 ~Defending force 23408 troops, 58 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 590
  M' {: |! m' K . R0 M  ~+ g) ^* x# w3 O
Allied engineers reduce fortifications to 7
! _' \9 T! `5 u3 f ( b& D, u1 r9 W& F
Allied max assault: 3322 - adjusted assault: 983   d) X- k( s# w

* }7 p+ P1 O# h# c# uJapanese max defense: 389 - adjusted defense: 195
2 G1 G7 ]3 E' |( @, O% |+ ]
6 q9 B6 B0 L! Z7 b. e. E2 K) mAllied assault odds: 5 to 1 (fort level 7) 3 S; p$ P  h" x% b# T
% J  J! P. M' U9 C7 @% H! `
Allied Assault reduces fortifications to 4: Q' H+ e( Y; |# T) [. Q
2 |. a9 R9 y4 I

+ `, q/ N7 }6 d! H& \5 J- C7 IJapanese ground losses:
0 W+ X' Z6 E% r0 k3589 casualties reported
- ~0 z+ a  h2 y( N/ P/ k2 eGuns lost 45" E. [' D- E+ @  \

' }% ?4 Y$ O) W2 e9 lAllied ground losses:
7 b" {. i# Y. S' e3 x* J9 ]% P0 T3650 casualties reported
. q2 L/ y5 l& W+ y6 N8 s7 yGuns lost 57
4 Y% T) H2 }  [- j$ \Vehicles lost 106( ~* t: Y) N+ i0 k

0 x/ {9 P9 \0 U* O5 Q! L/ a第二天攻克该岛。

hades1001

建议增加师团级单位继续测试

黑豹G

盟军兵力再次减少，仅由陆战1、2、3、4师发动进攻，由6个炮兵团提供辅助，火力准备依然不变。
' b! s% Y; @& t' k- CGround combat at Satawal
# S& {7 h1 z4 M$ K0 d$ l: G
* p3 z0 u* ~9 X1 L  U* T, [0 G$ tAllied Shock attack
9 z' ]7 d, z- t0 l
6 Z  n. M- W( @7 V% ~. L- HAttacking force 58266 troops, 569 guns, 45 vehicles, Assault Value = 1347
7 l4 v5 O8 H* h1 k6 m7 ?
9 M) A$ S3 u. d% X" P# _Defending force 24428 troops, 58 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 601
6 W2 M$ z1 a8 g6 L
/ f' ^( y9 N* b9 q; u1 _! tAllied engineers reduce fortifications to 8' P8 j  O  @9 B$ v
, g7 v# l' E) k" |2 h
Allied max assault: 2290 - adjusted assault: 716
0 a, b9 I& h& y: [- `- ~; G
2 U% f9 T5 J. tJapanese max defense: 426 - adjusted defense: 383 # d  H- `2 ]( x; k' n# w, ]! a

0 S8 i' B( x+ l% K! w' kAllied assault odds: 1 to 1 (fort level 8)
7 p7 z; ^5 q+ |) }$ V
2 N# D3 g+ ?6 w) ~& w% ]Allied Assault reduces fortifications to 8( U+ d- ~2 s7 }! Y: l" W/ u4 |8 T

; B- L' ?: \" w# U. r6 L& }4 s 7 H/ \+ U7 a0 }; A+ C  u
Japanese ground losses:( v" S$ P* a0 {+ `4 F0 i
3041 casualties reported
. z( u% l, d  \! [  k- D9 c/ rGuns lost 31
1 n. X1 @% h- M0 ~& \  b * T( T1 H" G/ V# X/ \% e# G: P2 v/ D
Allied ground losses:! A4 G. t* L# }" S% V7 p7 ~
3144 casualties reported
' g& L. C8 P5 c) e7 n1 h$ HGuns lost 57
! c/ I  f" Q% y# \: {5 [Vehicles lost 19
0 V5 J3 w' c- J" n4 H! S) b1 R. L$ t" i0 D8 R. D: [
由此可见，对付上述兵力的日军守备队，此兵力为临界点。

黑豹G

由近卫师团（451战斗力）替换4个海警队（432战斗力），岛上战斗力基本维持不变。

黑豹G

战斗结果大大出乎预料。
: c1 H, v: o& f0 V0 D9 Z美军4个师：陆战3、4师，第6、25步兵师和全部的炮工坦部队，一次突击就拿下了该岛) Y3 A# n* o1 ?8 u* D
Ground combat at Satawal
; p+ @8 n6 Y5 _5 v1 y3 O % I0 \9 H. ], s# t5 z
Allied Shock attack
1 M% n" F2 _* B( ]2 D# g
6 x  o+ K# i* S8 U) u* O0 xAttacking force 63995 troops, 555 guns, 530 vehicles, Assault Value = 1600
2 A1 _7 f- W: ?* R ! d/ S) b% I3 d% c7 ^" ^
Defending force 32850 troops, 291 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 6600 |6 Y6 g. E) `- ^. z% z; t

2 q, Y, n# e* _5 h& z0 v* AAllied max assault: 3266 - adjusted assault: 1518 2 D* {" @, w4 T( c
, w7 M8 g  ~7 H+ p
Japanese max defense: 359 - adjusted defense: 106
. o0 _1 _3 t& B+ Z; ?  H2 V/ \- q) c
, P5 l* ?/ d. c4 B) xAllied assault odds: 14 to 1 (fort level 9) : _7 P/ B; J' b
. b! N, N; U7 q1 B, i6 j6 s& Y/ S
Allied forces CAPTURE Satawal base !!!* a' G* D" f+ e* {
9 d# z; d2 e; K" g

& Z) f1 S9 F$ |$ P3 lJapanese ground losses:
" \, Q9 O- A6 e8 G5 h2875 casualties reported1 S# O/ }' N: W. ]" F
Guns lost 47
! o/ i( R: [& w) \' ^
: s' y, o) R6 W. H1 n5 OAllied ground losses:
0 o8 Y2 I& h' W  l# W, J! f$ x2742 casualties reported
  g. Q0 p# _0 J3 b4 AGuns lost 50
& }/ d$ h! }6 q: E" f# w) X9 W+ xVehicles lost 71

reninhat

看来500+坦克，的确厉害

黑豹G

使用和第二次实验完全相同的兵力，结果表明，近卫师团发挥实在欠佳 - d% `: ~& u, c2 u  y

5 d8 j2 S& R+ _Ground combat at Satawal; I6 _' Z, q7 m3 d( s+ W; Q: z# V1 `
7 ]! y( ~" ?1 T
Allied Shock attack- |* j# f$ x9 p* K

4 [1 K9 @/ \" W  f" W8 p9 nAttacking force 77120 troops, 685 guns, 540 vehicles, Assault Value = 2046
. z" J9 T: ?1 a
8 K' v$ O; g( RDefending force 35166 troops, 292 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 695
! U% T- n: N; Q6 ^! `' S4 i+ u
3 k- G  p7 Y0 R. x; p9 ~Allied engineers reduce fortifications to 8
1 |! @8 N2 Q( \% {8 v 9 W2 c6 a% p( d9 C: s1 N
Allied max assault: 3770 - adjusted assault: 1764
) K$ w& s. [5 m/ L4 d3 D* e * V& C/ G5 Q- }9 w
Japanese max defense: 395 - adjusted defense: 126
3 g2 L/ a4 ~, {* C. n- s# R
( |! v  [5 [6 m" ZAllied assault odds: 14 to 1 (fort level 8) 8 z" H, Q. f3 x5 }# q

7 {' A# S1 z6 x/ bAllied forces CAPTURE Satawal base !!!
# h2 i' N, j' Y/ ^: C' O8 L ; w; {0 ?/ }( w9 Y& E9 ^
% @" ]& d) e" a8 Z) F, d5 B& l) r2 |+ F
Japanese ground losses:
: u* u% Q* i- \5 T4971 casualties reported
7 T& f. f2 D4 @1 dGuns lost 64
# f/ S3 G9 K9 V& @2 I 8 Q9 J/ S2 Z# t4 D1 C- F
Allied ground losses:1 L0 ]- h6 K# G- c3 J# K8 D
1430 casualties reported
+ d2 D9 N  y  s  D7 J7 w2 N$ p2 UGuns lost 69
' t" T2 F0 u* BVehicles lost 66

黑豹G

盟军去掉了坦克部队，为平衡计，新投入了亚美利加师和41步兵师，结果一样把近卫师团打得满地找牙……
6 }/ P0 k( R2 T* c7 H- u  m3 YGround combat at Satawal9 g6 i& a3 d0 I& l- x  O

. G4 i- G1 ^& j7 u' a2 FAllied Shock attack* C. Q- A' d5 N* R3 Y7 [

# F. m. n+ V3 K! k  ?# \7 \. bAttacking force 84239 troops, 828 guns, 44 vehicles, Assault Value = 1942% a# R, P2 T+ ~1 X1 j

, |8 p8 x1 `* b. q# UDefending force 35202 troops, 265 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 6953 [8 V( [0 z6 ]6 p2 {9 _

2 a0 f+ M3 y+ x; ]1 }Allied engineers reduce fortifications to 7, s* p' y- E. Q' ^, i0 C
' ~: V, ?& ^$ p5 T
Allied max assault: 3412 - adjusted assault: 1394
* m4 v% S) M% ~: C
; U) T$ j0 h- a2 K: ~Japanese max defense: 413 - adjusted defense: 165
; P6 Q2 F4 h3 X5 X2 s3 y   u8 s3 g- H: v! V# }0 F
Allied assault odds: 8 to 1 (fort level 7)
7 g9 K! V$ y+ C, W $ @8 \8 g9 ]: O/ h) l: T0 C( v
Allied Assault reduces fortifications to 1
( p; Z  X5 F" `  h7 H / F) v/ V- U+ r

6 E% r, ^: t. E9 u6 x: Q% Q  GJapanese ground losses:1 L/ C; t. V$ B- R+ W
3652 casualties reported1 P9 f1 F" X7 d5 d! u
Guns lost 55
) W; [9 S. C3 b3 @7 \! ^, o; \3 {
0 i! @/ p- V: I7 G, MAllied ground losses:
# [1 b* c% ~; H: c. D) `- l9 j& @3429 casualties reported
0 J0 c0 j  F6 s7 [5 f$ mGuns lost 94& k" n( D3 q, U% `! n6 p- @
Vehicles lost 11

黑豹G

加入第1岸炮联队

蔷薇骑士团

靠 / R* r9 d% t# `1 z$ ^) \2 a2 J
居然这么离谱！这下日军的放血战术也搞不下去了，都不知道是在放谁的血 $ i* @; K# J4 R
太可悲了

黑豹G

使用和第六次完全相同的兵力。. a  w  K7 S+ g
登陆部队被岸炮打击非常严重。/ C- G; l" O* ?
Coastal Guns at Satawal, 60,74, firing at TF 1005
& U' e0 y. v( u* {8 c( j1 ?TF 1005 troops unloading over beach at Satawal, 60,74
" Q9 H/ C% K3 D! k: W
  b) y  c5 ~* D0 f ; Z/ t  G, {' c7 V7 N$ ]5 o
1782 Coastal gun shots fired in defense.* C" U6 [2 z3 O( b( e
Allied Ships2 z; J3 @- _- u2 n2 V7 r/ Z
AO Schuylkill, Shell hits 6,  on fire/ v" Z# }6 n. W' c! \% ?6 B
AO Saugatuck, Shell hits 14,  on fire! T% z0 n; {* T& E' w6 T: ]2 O
AK Cetus, Shell hits 3,  on fire- m0 K4 ?" s7 ]* E( J7 ^! b
AK Cassiopeia, Shell hits 1/ ^8 U7 Z& i1 x9 b
AO Saranac, Shell hits 14,  on fire,  heavy damage$ |3 S% `+ j" W4 w9 z0 f  E
AO Suamico, Shell hits 6,  on fire3 O' E: Q# a2 B7 ]! x& r0 \- X1 o
AO Taluga, Shell hits 15,  on fire,  heavy damage
. X8 E9 ^4 U) @: _' d" A' u* |AK PT-24, Shell hits 18,  on fire,  heavy damage( e9 v; ~8 R& u* u2 a  D7 w- C
AK Alshain, Shell hits 15,  on fire,  heavy damage
6 n7 O; G/ o: T' y9 _( BAGP Mobjack, Shell hits 9,  on fire,  heavy damage( A8 z: ?; l( j5 d! C
AK Virgo, Shell hits 5,  on fire,  heavy damage
) U+ a% _  }  |$ w; y  mAK Alkes, Shell hits 12,  on fire& u4 ?+ Q) o. f3 t# H. L0 P
AK Allioth, Shell hits 4,  on fire
- E! Y' {1 z$ ]# S( z/ YAS Clytie, Shell hits 10,  on fire,  heavy damage
* f! }" r/ v( [0 X! Z , Y$ Y" A& i; W6 }. ~
; M7 a, d' C' X# i
Allied ground losses:$ g3 N8 i' n8 H- F+ U8 M2 h8 K
10243 casualties reported* b, E) _. W& o( e# U. \( R
Guns lost 339 j- ]) G% p9 u, c

& Y% l. C/ e2 e' H/ i; G- \Coastal Guns at Satawal, 60,74, firing at TF 1002! {' P, d' v; |- R" X
TF 1002 troops unloading over beach at Satawal, 60,74
, H. Y6 s: o+ a5 L6 _9 [ , N1 U4 @- O5 Q0 a9 r, L$ z

8 x6 n; I8 o/ ~393 Coastal gun shots fired in defense.* ]9 r% ~% q- b
Allied Ships' K" T! \7 T# q" D. d! Y! x
DMS Long$ z8 \1 Q% K4 ?4 B
LST LST-207, Shell hits 8,  on fire,  heavy damage$ Q# B' F0 M$ w, h3 S( b1 q0 S
DMS Hopkins, Shell hits 5,  on fire,  heavy damage* @) l4 B% U* C0 a% q; Q
SC SC-1064, Shell hits 9,  on fire,  heavy damage
" c# q6 U& \' v) ^  XLST LST-125
) D* p; H! b. W; q+ HSC SC-1063, Shell hits 3,  on fire,  heavy damage
- f6 w( }/ z% D/ p. O- DLST LST-123, Shell hits 19,  on fire,  heavy damage
) ?$ l3 B. K# L1 ?( A8 b5 [LST LST-40, Shell hits 6,  on fire,  heavy damage
) ~; O+ A6 F; |0 H& D" fSC SC-739, Shell hits 7,  on fire,  heavy damage
+ X5 X& R4 F/ f1 v* N' N  ^LST LST-21, Shell hits 24,  on fire,  heavy damage
8 _& ^+ K! Y. z7 p6 a" l
( b- s8 d1 ?. W( h
. t( p1 h! k! _Allied ground losses:. Y- b! S- K9 H1 {! k& E
7403 casualties reported
7 `$ U* m0 I- m% e( g7 fGuns lost 53  ~6 Z9 P) t3 K& u8 b! h3 {0 P
9 t/ h) W& x  w' I: V6 U3 z$ W
但是近卫师团依然发挥不理想
' G# P/ I$ r4 G8 h* h4 P  J0 HGround combat at Satawal# Y/ W* J' g+ t+ a
7 [8 n; C! y) t5 n  V
Allied Shock attack  r7 s9 n8 S- ~& D

5 `5 }% ?/ e" W1 r. P- lAttacking force 76608 troops, 763 guns, 51 vehicles, Assault Value = 1841
( ?, D, e6 O! G0 m% v, x1 ^6 y- c + ?4 E8 f4 s& p) R# c6 N
Defending force 37275 troops, 335 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 690
( d2 ^% j3 C4 h7 b7 T! _& z ) u0 A  w& H/ J& K; ?2 [
Allied max assault: 3382 - adjusted assault: 1310 0 [  f( _5 n( A( j0 w
3 S5 B( z$ H. [; X7 z
Japanese max defense: 458 - adjusted defense: 142
! ^7 `: w6 q' N# H; d/ V% t( v
; j: Z$ J1 {/ _Allied assault odds: 8 to 1 (fort level 9)
8 J0 E% V; m) `& i & c$ A. ^6 q4 C: j
Allied Assault reduces fortifications to 2
  }. X5 h9 S  d# G& |) y
3 d; E  r8 Z. Q% @, s8 q
' W$ d- V- M5 KJapanese ground losses:7 d2 a6 S8 n; F! `, v6 _4 o
3894 casualties reported
, C2 T1 T( S2 {) V: |/ d3 k( FGuns lost 75
, N/ @% }$ V$ a) o+ q! k 7 o6 k/ n1 Y4 u; k/ E- H
Allied ground losses:. V. T+ F9 U8 b2 l% p  `$ y
3278 casualties reported
% E/ [2 x* b) FGuns lost 821 d  j- i/ I0 w4 x2 A2 V0 ^7 ]
Vehicles lost 20

Donnie_Brasco

日军才一个师团么，多放两个美军还不得吐血。

黑豹G

第2岸炮联队投入

reninhat

近卫师团的经验和士气多少？