ANDY准备投降了？
* z( w- N( W0 w5 @7 a, F% [" i- ~" M8 q, @8 k
Hi yes I have about 40 subs in Tinian waters and approaches but they are doing limited good.4 R" Z4 o6 j: K" ~
1 Z* y1 {/ m# XOK today I only got 0:1 so its game over on Tinian.
# E8 \3 Y7 t) G+ G5 q [- M$ v
# X" w3 y+ \- s8 W# e% c0 NOK a few points for everyone thank you for the email questions but its easier to answer them on the forum en masse so to speak.
4 b5 u* A* H$ ?* @ Q$ `8 \: ?& u# w/ ]5 X6 Y
If I miss anyones questions apologies
+ Q5 R5 C' S; D8 M" g& x$ ]
9 W. Y. Y, L, I( L1. Why did you attack Tinian and not another island in the Marianas.
# d9 h2 k- _2 u+ }
9 w* G6 Z1 `, U5 {7 u) OAll other islands are mountainous so Tinian has a x 4 AV multiple for forts, Saipan, Guam or Pagan would have x 12 because forts and mountains are mutiplactive. i.e. attacking the Marianas for the allies is a no choice option.
9 n4 h( q5 ]' Y# a4 ~' N; D; x
4 p$ M1 B1 Q: O5 T+ T2. Why did you not bomb before attacking.
2 R. f: S0 G) S# t( u( n- j& q: h, T, F& s
Because it is not possible in WITP to interdict land reinforcements if the Japanese player is willing to take the losses he can put 2 or 3 Divs ashore in short order either by transport aircraft or massed AK invasion - Pauk did that to me at Gasmata so he knows the moves and PZB has completed it many times another 1,000 AV x 4 = no matter what the allies bring its not possible.2 X$ z8 Y4 e t( L% b
$ ?% Q# }- D3 E1 V
3. Why did you not sweep the mines before landing ?
" k( _9 B% ^3 L. ~! _- N3 W# e7 q# r! X4 ]! T6 o& C
Over 40 MSWs were destroyed int he first hour of the fight despite having DD and BB support int he same TF.
$ ]" }0 Z+ Q2 h1 M( K5 D j: U8 f3 }: E$ J
4. Why did you give up on SWPAC7 t7 S, M% I9 i6 w( s5 {
* E, ` B i. f! k q' ySWPAC is a valid attack route BUT with every base having lvl 9 forts and the Japanese able to reinforce and it being malaria it is a VERY tough attack route. Remember Noemfoor against PZB a single Bde can stop 2 - 3 Divs of allied Troops for a long time. Forts are just to strong in jungle and Malaria.8 G6 F0 ~0 @0 i5 @9 O2 O
6 g3 @% g: F# }# T: ^/ {7 u; v
5. Why not attack Marcus
# t7 C P( k. r6 o; Y) y
( q0 o/ d! n4 | K0 pPerhaps I should have valid question1 a( S% H7 P0 \! W+ O- D& t
8 j0 J; p% O# N4 ^3 }6 T6. Why not attack HI; Z1 v8 q6 `- F2 ]! i
$ w" o% h( h! V4 ~. T6 u+ c
Because although I would have won it would have left a bad taste in the mouth.
( s8 f7 J2 X. V( G! y/ {0 d4 h. _3 r( V5 l( I+ a( v% G% U0 A
OK what now - honest answer I dont know! X% z, W8 q- `; d
Andy |
发表于 2007-9-18 17:45
| 
