对盟军环礁登岛战役的实验

黑豹G

实验场地：环礁岛屿萨塔瓦尔Satawal、9级城防、盟军从沃勒爱Wuleai出发。
* J8 I9 u& m6 w6 t& a$ R  Q实验兵力：盟军18个师    陆战1、2、3、4师，第3、6、7、24、25、27、30、37、40、41、43步兵师，骑1师，
" N3 ^4 ?* i2 \8 a  h; G                 亚美利加师，澳大利亚第6师。   第18、19、47战斗工兵团，11个坦克营，17个炮兵团，中太平洋司令部，8 }$ n4 O1 s! Q1 O! f' d# w6 E" ~! o
                 美第6集团军，美第3，9，10军。
# D% d: K& c% m# a9 l                 日军兵力 吴镇守府第1、2陆战队，第44、62、63、64海警队，日本陆军132基地部队，第33军司令部。
# @& W9 A$ y4 ~; O. E0 ~, n战斗过程：由盟军22艘CV轰炸3天，登陆当天16艘BB分两队进行炮击。- C$ m. t. [. d5 ]/ G0 f* @
战斗评价：重锤砸鸡蛋，毫无悬念，3支部队直接被歼灭，战斗工兵将城防直接从9降到3。5 X! d% O. X4 b3 I: Q8 O  x
战斗报告：Ground combat at Satawal
4 r; v; s! H# _  u5 j& X* A1 {- R7 T  F1 R% J7 H8 y, N" J# F
                  Allied Shock attack$ e& Q  s, z% f! _
5 k' ?! \; j7 U! d) ]7 @! d" Z! z$ E
                  Attacking force 230295 troops, 2040 guns, 548 vehicles, Assault Value = 5624
( V# c2 B- k' ~; v7 M1 P2 W5 u( p2 W. h/ I: k
                  Defending force 23017 troops, 45 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 587! @3 q* H  }; a5 t! ^

2 v' }% B, Q% o4 ^  L, `8 q3 x                  Allied engineers reduce fortifications to 3! d. X- q% K/ d$ k$ T+ F# p
2 z  r. Z, {# f3 ~% `* b# x
                  Allied max assault: 8784 - adjusted assault: 4806 ) H; j# J0 h2 O! Z3 Q  K
& L9 [/ |8 c$ V, e: |9 L( |
                  Japanese max defense: 381 - adjusted defense: 95 2 S  I2 ^4 k: C; Z
. s* L* [* b; k/ a4 j6 L9 f
                  Allied assault odds: 50 to 1 (fort level 3) - }/ t) @$ _& _, P
! V8 z* ?5 e! D. ]8 C; r$ Y. }
                  Allied forces CAPTURE Satawal base !!!3 t5 a; \; o, \. K

: U6 V; Q0 g. p4 W+ h4 S1 b0 H3 U! m4 e' {4 M: M9 c
                  Japanese ground losses:
" x! V- K9 u8 M- p5 U( J" v# ^                  5806 casualties reported
  a8 _  q2 i9 e2 S$ H. R/ g                  Guns lost 30
- @. o; M; h+ }4 N& L) D$ E
2 @4 l3 A3 D2 [- g6 Q                  Allied ground losses:( }$ `/ H( u8 G- _1 M
                  5263 casualties reported" d, F% ]4 N; y1 X: @) }  f
                  Guns lost 1281 R. [8 I) H, Q, S1 h
                  Vehicles lost 863 R6 c6 U* `1 ]& y

5 i  W7 x' X9 Z[ 本帖最后由 黑豹G 于 2007-12-4 19:20 编辑 ]

黑豹G

盟军兵力减少，为陆战1、2、3、4师，澳大利亚第6师，全部的装甲和辅助部队，火力准备不变。
( \# g# M% \# I$ I战斗结果：
  |' L4 O7 ]6 K; S4 p* wGround combat at Satawal: o8 d# a* o/ Y/ K

1 F( a+ a& E5 l+ h. ?6 e( gAllied Shock attack
3 O8 z* D8 c! _5 U
1 O2 H/ p% d3 h/ r# cAttacking force 77949 troops, 685 guns, 548 vehicles, Assault Value = 2044$ @  R) q* m1 s6 d
4 C. `+ |2 y3 U: Y4 D  c9 y3 N
Defending force 23408 troops, 58 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 5907 L3 d& Q* ?. Q0 F1 x+ k

% @% Q3 ^1 b9 H) U+ r  Q5 ^! [Allied engineers reduce fortifications to 7  {) I, C7 R* Z, h" d
% [. I( O: f1 S# a' O
Allied max assault: 3322 - adjusted assault: 983 & m3 g2 F( P& j/ ~! w& d( T

( }  {! y' h* a. F  U' z) ?$ _Japanese max defense: 389 - adjusted defense: 195
( L- ^6 \7 a3 n9 V! G; K0 f
3 ?& y& ?* H. n; Q; o3 K  \Allied assault odds: 5 to 1 (fort level 7) - q' ?# l) j2 Q. f

" m! M# t. i0 K6 [Allied Assault reduces fortifications to 4
  C5 ]& ?' {& j: h4 V; ?% ^. r 0 \! C' \0 S8 ]( S7 h5 g/ s$ c

& i( n& x9 D; @8 pJapanese ground losses:
- D, P7 W! h7 l6 s7 @2 S3 d; S: m3589 casualties reported6 S1 x/ Y  f; A0 u% C+ X2 K. {
Guns lost 45
8 w! D% N0 F# F" }+ A
0 h& F9 A' O5 o% {7 v" ]) ~$ HAllied ground losses:
* S  H( U8 g5 T% W! [3650 casualties reported4 C' t6 c% s) j0 a
Guns lost 57
# j2 F/ {7 c: a0 U4 w# m" \Vehicles lost 1067 `. K2 m; k' t7 p8 a9 k

7 F9 b! @2 x3 c# }第二天攻克该岛。

hades1001

建议增加师团级单位继续测试

黑豹G

盟军兵力再次减少，仅由陆战1、2、3、4师发动进攻，由6个炮兵团提供辅助，火力准备依然不变。
2 k5 F5 Y" C/ G7 i3 m; b2 ZGround combat at Satawal" q$ |1 }2 B) V, ]6 u

$ y, D0 |+ o4 o3 l: V7 VAllied Shock attack: f" j* O: t- @

; x2 s- G1 v+ QAttacking force 58266 troops, 569 guns, 45 vehicles, Assault Value = 13470 P, r6 ~# E- c, M+ B  g

! ]% y3 f5 c7 O8 T0 X) q; s4 S- F8 K" ^Defending force 24428 troops, 58 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 6015 _& h! N' p& [5 m5 g+ G' U6 D
5 W" B# N, `0 L& {" J
Allied engineers reduce fortifications to 8
  @4 c/ ~6 S2 P1 I3 w6 L % Z7 m3 q9 i- v) V1 k1 h
Allied max assault: 2290 - adjusted assault: 716
6 |! T+ @0 K% ^* G* I
" p. H; e9 C. ?Japanese max defense: 426 - adjusted defense: 383 + E4 M6 \+ s  U. c; D: q

+ S0 t8 j! [9 v9 a8 D+ E8 J7 wAllied assault odds: 1 to 1 (fort level 8)
% m' [5 o$ x. J% e: |$ o
: `1 h: @% N( b- |4 d! mAllied Assault reduces fortifications to 8! n5 ~$ ]9 g/ q/ _
0 O7 o3 h# o( j$ y

3 o% [5 v- L! a2 e& |% gJapanese ground losses:
  w/ u+ t6 ^( p  u  t! U: P3041 casualties reported
* s+ A8 Z3 v; f& jGuns lost 31
- O4 t; o/ W# P$ `$ t0 V2 [/ E1 K* P / ~2 f7 s% U! Q" v5 b' D/ o" R
Allied ground losses:/ V+ P' R0 z. h7 A
3144 casualties reported! |& C' a0 _0 ]2 I8 G4 G0 V5 a1 a
Guns lost 57) M; x4 x5 r3 N; ^/ c, M% I
Vehicles lost 19
8 @" D+ }" ~1 f, Z! b0 z% ^: I: N
4 b' c2 O; U6 M由此可见，对付上述兵力的日军守备队，此兵力为临界点。

黑豹G

由近卫师团（451战斗力）替换4个海警队（432战斗力），岛上战斗力基本维持不变。

黑豹G

战斗结果大大出乎预料。
" f, V6 d  y: K- s  z: p' {4 u* h4 H- ?美军4个师：陆战3、4师，第6、25步兵师和全部的炮工坦部队，一次突击就拿下了该岛
% v+ f& x* j" ~Ground combat at Satawal5 r9 H9 P7 v$ V2 k( b8 h# _, A
5 P+ E: [" K- e$ |1 m/ q
Allied Shock attack
- A3 Y" m) X8 q3 m" j 1 w% A) @8 C5 n( |  V
Attacking force 63995 troops, 555 guns, 530 vehicles, Assault Value = 1600
3 p9 c, F3 m7 M( m& l6 ]' Y! P% a
( U; O; u. o* D% u# I" W5 A6 nDefending force 32850 troops, 291 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 660
7 U4 A/ l. p" ~3 I/ J
! X9 K. |) g/ T% LAllied max assault: 3266 - adjusted assault: 1518
& `+ m0 k4 k6 N! D3 a* e& Z% v
$ B7 n5 w3 z- l6 Z, W1 TJapanese max defense: 359 - adjusted defense: 106 ! q3 m) M8 d- ]
- f- W/ W$ Q- Z# t/ G& C4 |
Allied assault odds: 14 to 1 (fort level 9) + ~6 Q: e- D+ t5 g' G" K5 l

: K: N. O5 ^+ O- b, S% c3 fAllied forces CAPTURE Satawal base !!!" c1 E0 h( e) u1 g$ |8 M
4 f2 b3 e9 H8 R% f

1 |8 c' C- Y3 @5 p4 O* D  {' m+ AJapanese ground losses:
* J6 }' M9 c6 n1 L2875 casualties reported  h9 g: [- y7 v0 N. H
Guns lost 470 d1 ?' T4 _0 c! ~2 _7 i

/ @+ ^3 q0 U. M9 N' b' DAllied ground losses:
8 k7 D9 @8 D* _9 g. @# w2742 casualties reported) m: X  K! y, Q% A
Guns lost 50) j0 ]2 ~6 [  P" t
Vehicles lost 71

reninhat

看来500+坦克，的确厉害

黑豹G

使用和第二次实验完全相同的兵力，结果表明，近卫师团发挥实在欠佳
- B: Q1 r. \* r7 n+ @  a
$ Z6 H, ]- b1 l0 I6 V0 E  j! ZGround combat at Satawal
* V6 F( u: m. m, M0 |+ G! L 0 B. ?" x, |+ K. O/ {: m
Allied Shock attack/ J5 ~% P( ~7 l2 P

6 \' _' {0 k0 o, ?/ N$ \7 xAttacking force 77120 troops, 685 guns, 540 vehicles, Assault Value = 2046! c6 w  b5 W2 b  z) K
1 f; E+ m3 F* q& o- o# S& m
Defending force 35166 troops, 292 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 695" R" r( N+ x  G, L
, s8 M# C$ V! |& h! B+ K0 z* a
Allied engineers reduce fortifications to 8  n; j8 G, J* ]/ U4 j- F, M

5 A' S, `0 |+ g* v; aAllied max assault: 3770 - adjusted assault: 1764
/ C+ o5 p+ ^' A! F1 ]! ] * Z7 r8 p/ _+ {& z( U) g* b, {
Japanese max defense: 395 - adjusted defense: 126
- E. v7 A, u' y5 j ! A+ V' Q/ ~* ~3 o! m0 n! |" d) ~
Allied assault odds: 14 to 1 (fort level 8)
$ q4 y; S+ j  g+ I/ Y0 t6 H) A: e
4 K1 l; a2 g. m, yAllied forces CAPTURE Satawal base !!!
5 l3 j% A$ W  D: Z  n  }
; w) I5 H: m. Q 9 C, H2 ?) h- i7 J0 }( u: ~8 C% ]. X
Japanese ground losses:
. X  V( x* ^. R. q4971 casualties reported
, b: N% q, w" c4 bGuns lost 64
& R; t) G: _3 Y& V
: n# {: s! i& c7 E1 }1 e4 v- c# yAllied ground losses:
) `- g. [4 z; n: h# o5 c1430 casualties reported
! B2 t, m- h% r. e& f/ dGuns lost 69
0 Y! M! |% ~- }4 R  I! s) w' ^; DVehicles lost 66

黑豹G

盟军去掉了坦克部队，为平衡计，新投入了亚美利加师和41步兵师，结果一样把近卫师团打得满地找牙……
  C- h( n. l* DGround combat at Satawal8 }6 `) y5 d/ n4 R% o: S( p4 v8 u

6 Y" W" T9 F; ?, M, _! q% k1 |" CAllied Shock attack: r; g% H" ~7 T- f/ ?) v+ ?
# R; w) E0 }& ]/ l
Attacking force 84239 troops, 828 guns, 44 vehicles, Assault Value = 1942
2 @( d. }9 l# t 6 _4 c$ ?7 V; V5 u- G4 j0 k
Defending force 35202 troops, 265 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 695% A4 o& D: ?, B7 D
6 v' l) d6 ~' m  [3 r, |
Allied engineers reduce fortifications to 7
" D' ~: ]2 O( S$ t0 D
! \2 D+ c5 E5 R1 UAllied max assault: 3412 - adjusted assault: 1394
# }$ H" {, C9 h
6 X/ S+ \; i# C6 dJapanese max defense: 413 - adjusted defense: 165
2 [# R8 D# K8 u9 V; ^5 J
( T( f# p! b7 h( T; }- `0 BAllied assault odds: 8 to 1 (fort level 7)
- K. ]2 ?/ P# B0 p+ a$ R
+ B" t$ b0 r; s  o0 x. C0 `Allied Assault reduces fortifications to 1
3 ^& t, I: [8 t; j5 W3 @/ Q $ z" T, L# u8 I5 }+ ?

5 O& ~/ e* H" o! @  e; \0 @Japanese ground losses:
$ }6 x$ J% D- ]2 P3652 casualties reported
' ^- T- G$ p3 G1 j: S: \0 TGuns lost 55- s' p( L; t- Y; k; X7 H

/ c1 L2 u. x; e! XAllied ground losses:
+ p+ v" z3 ~( u0 v! F5 u9 O/ j& [& \$ ?3429 casualties reported
) b# |8 ^1 \- ]: rGuns lost 94
3 Y+ [! l# }+ I$ e7 ]! W3 tVehicles lost 11

黑豹G

加入第1岸炮联队

蔷薇骑士团

靠 % k( o8 _  v2 e: z, [; g. P; r
居然这么离谱！这下日军的放血战术也搞不下去了，都不知道是在放谁的血 3 G6 g9 y! {! C2 `$ S
太可悲了

黑豹G

使用和第六次完全相同的兵力。6 ?  b$ X- t  a* _8 P! ]
登陆部队被岸炮打击非常严重。  c. |  v4 L  u1 Y3 o. I+ r
Coastal Guns at Satawal, 60,74, firing at TF 1005
, T0 H# I- G* f7 L+ hTF 1005 troops unloading over beach at Satawal, 60,74. j, l  A) b$ R; D9 \; Y; S
- s4 ?# P' ?! Q8 D
* X* g3 s, R/ t2 j6 Y
1782 Coastal gun shots fired in defense.
/ O$ r  z6 z) f) ?" DAllied Ships8 Q" D, j) r2 q, Q) q+ l
AO Schuylkill, Shell hits 6,  on fire2 `5 V, }* @( D) E6 |) D1 q( f* M
AO Saugatuck, Shell hits 14,  on fire' u8 J0 ]# j! `4 W
AK Cetus, Shell hits 3,  on fire! e! {2 i6 m# k: c! ]" t6 ]7 v
AK Cassiopeia, Shell hits 1! O7 [) f) @: a5 [' l9 s# G8 q
AO Saranac, Shell hits 14,  on fire,  heavy damage
- A# T$ }$ C/ |+ r( c( B, jAO Suamico, Shell hits 6,  on fire
4 _( B+ q1 E. q, I" JAO Taluga, Shell hits 15,  on fire,  heavy damage7 }3 A# b9 z4 T
AK PT-24, Shell hits 18,  on fire,  heavy damage
) ]- E# q0 l1 @# Y/ D* RAK Alshain, Shell hits 15,  on fire,  heavy damage) z- r2 @$ P6 S
AGP Mobjack, Shell hits 9,  on fire,  heavy damage
' }! k" [8 y* U% A+ \AK Virgo, Shell hits 5,  on fire,  heavy damage! @$ Q" ^- ^9 F
AK Alkes, Shell hits 12,  on fire1 W8 h6 B, m0 f
AK Allioth, Shell hits 4,  on fire
! B: F6 p8 G# P5 [0 Z7 z- ]AS Clytie, Shell hits 10,  on fire,  heavy damage( I% N7 f8 T* Z0 ?* r" a8 g0 f  f" d

$ ]- {& l9 B1 Y$ w  D- u4 D
; q$ F  c& L/ B: m( eAllied ground losses:" P( r; T" W+ L. W0 D* G
10243 casualties reported
1 }0 R& f0 ^' `0 m1 A+ S: a& MGuns lost 338 N$ ?* d/ m! |* m2 ]) U/ v
* d9 g' [6 P5 m  y4 \" G
Coastal Guns at Satawal, 60,74, firing at TF 1002# Y! o+ Y* l8 b" Z- {
TF 1002 troops unloading over beach at Satawal, 60,74
# S" ^+ P, q3 S5 [  q, N
/ C' x9 y8 v/ q& y/ v+ u! s. B9 @ 1 ], j; B/ H+ L& e& M
393 Coastal gun shots fired in defense.0 m$ o- S0 n$ g# J) O. z- a2 Z
Allied Ships+ ]3 R4 Q& t9 b0 R# b8 {7 E- A5 ^
DMS Long  Y, ~" z, A1 t3 m
LST LST-207, Shell hits 8,  on fire,  heavy damage
' h. ?/ Y1 W: O. t; ?" W/ zDMS Hopkins, Shell hits 5,  on fire,  heavy damage
/ b) X8 T! n; j# ]; oSC SC-1064, Shell hits 9,  on fire,  heavy damage
5 l3 [, ^8 t7 |6 Q# P3 yLST LST-125, `/ J& s6 Z: R7 b6 X* y
SC SC-1063, Shell hits 3,  on fire,  heavy damage: A) a( e4 A6 T6 }% Q4 r
LST LST-123, Shell hits 19,  on fire,  heavy damage$ X% Y' y, Z& q; M' A
LST LST-40, Shell hits 6,  on fire,  heavy damage
. D8 P  C" |: ?; z* Q' {$ ySC SC-739, Shell hits 7,  on fire,  heavy damage
4 K3 R& C( }* O1 hLST LST-21, Shell hits 24,  on fire,  heavy damage
) b9 r9 Y/ R$ r' M3 e
% _2 i# ~' R% b( R& G$ \+ T
7 ]0 V! i* F+ B4 o, k4 U! PAllied ground losses:
' H! }8 d/ l3 c, _4 _; t: w0 w# Z+ b7403 casualties reported
4 i; T9 P: O! n: a6 s& iGuns lost 53, `( J7 g, x$ h& ~1 o: g
% G! k$ t2 R3 j
但是近卫师团依然发挥不理想9 ?# K; [6 N4 k; G  P
Ground combat at Satawal
/ p) N2 V) B/ G' k* C % B0 F3 O5 Z+ `" Q, ?8 K
Allied Shock attack
0 U: H' c* \% Y( x
( k8 P. u' n5 |9 qAttacking force 76608 troops, 763 guns, 51 vehicles, Assault Value = 1841" J* I, h' Z( l5 T* t
( A1 R' S5 l& t
Defending force 37275 troops, 335 guns, 0 vehicles, Assault Value = 690
6 u" f2 A1 d0 U+ ?6 ~! w" A# T/ n / ^- |0 M+ R5 v
Allied max assault: 3382 - adjusted assault: 1310
. S! e+ l  L, h4 V9 `0 c6 j- V ) w5 o. ]' g# L& j' V8 h; K5 r
Japanese max defense: 458 - adjusted defense: 142
1 ]* `1 e! z$ X/ G1 t
$ I/ k$ Q5 s1 T( V$ R8 ]' cAllied assault odds: 8 to 1 (fort level 9)
: V4 J4 \$ p; Q1 C: w6 q + y$ o+ v' [$ k: x/ H: H; K
Allied Assault reduces fortifications to 2: ^( d0 D! l* A  E2 L8 C9 E

& K' }* C$ k: M0 S% x 3 e/ Y' ^( D0 k( X/ D6 q9 j6 J
Japanese ground losses:
6 T4 ?3 h) c+ A2 [0 [/ l3894 casualties reported
9 R, R, F8 l6 e0 d4 e( SGuns lost 75. _' W6 `) x4 s; f* q+ Y" d" e1 H; Q

3 C  ?" e3 ?( YAllied ground losses:
! ~' y4 R( z" f. `3278 casualties reported
* N( o9 X. ]  Z! p% mGuns lost 82
1 U$ a- n# f, |" ^! X3 ~& S( K. NVehicles lost 20

Donnie_Brasco

日军才一个师团么，多放两个美军还不得吐血。

黑豹G

第2岸炮联队投入

reninhat

近卫师团的经验和士气多少？